Rakugo Netacho / All stories / Comic
Illustration of a scene from the rakugo story Toki Soba

Toki SobaSoba and the Time Trick

時そば(ときそば)

Late on a winter night, a man paying at a soba noodle stall asks "What time is it?" in the middle of counting out his coins, and cheats the seller out of one coin. Another man who saw it all is so impressed that he goes out the next night to copy the trick, but...

Category
Comic story (kokkei-banashi)
Style
Edo (Tokyo style). In Kamigata (Osaka-Kyoto style) it is Toki Udon
Also written
The title is also written 刻そば or 時蕎麦
Origin
"Tanin wa Kuu yori" in Karukuchi Hatsuwarai, a joke book from 1726 (Kyoho 11)
Transmission
Yanagiya Kosan III is said to have brought the Kamigata Toki Udon to Tokyo in the Meiji era
Season
Winter
CategoryComic storyFood story
CharactersThe man who cheats on the billThe man who copies himTwo soba sellers
SettingThe town at nightA nihachi soba stall
HighlightsSlurping sobaThe rhythm of counting coinsDescribing terrible soba

The story

Late on a cold winter night, a man stops a passing nihachi soba stall (a street-side noodle stand). He praises everything: the sign is nice, the chopsticks are fresh disposable ones, the bowl is nice, the broth is nice, the chikuwa (fish cake) is cut thick. Praising all the while, he finishes a bowl.

The bill is sixteen mon. "My change is all small coins, hold out your hand," he says, and counts one-mon coins into the seller's palm one at a time. At eight, he asks, "What time is it?" The seller answers, "It's nine," and the man carries right on, "ten, eleven..." up to sixteen, and is gone. He has cheated the seller out of one coin.

Another man was watching from the shadows. Seeing through the trick, he is deeply impressed, and the next day, unable to wait, he heads out early with a fistful of small coins.

But the stall he finds is awful. The chopsticks have been used before, the bowl is chipped, the broth is too salty, the noodles are soggy, and what he took for chikuwa is a cheap imitation called chikuwabu. Still, he starts counting coins just like the night before, and at eight he asks, "What time is it?"...

The sage the punchline, contains spoilers

Tap to reveal the punchline

"It's four, sir." "Five, six, seven, eight..."

The sage (the punchline) works because Edo-period hours were called by numbers, and at night "four" (around 10 p.m.) came just before "nine" (around midnight). Having gone out too early, the man hears "four," has to keep counting from five, and ends up paying extra instead of cheating. The Kamigata Toki Udon has the same sage.

Toki Soba in the east, Toki Udon in the west

The story was originally the Kamigata Toki Udon, and the setup of the characters changed when it moved to Tokyo. The Kamigata version is distinctive for having two men go to the stall together.

Toki Soba (Edo)Toki Udon (Kamigata)
What they eatNihachi soba from a stallUdon from a stall
First nightOne man cheats the seller while another watches from the shadowsTwo men, an older and a younger. The older one eats almost all of it and cheats on the bill
Second nightThe man who watched copies the trick at a terrible soba stallThe younger one goes alone and tries to reenact everything, even his exchange with the older one the night before
HistoryYanagiya Kosan III is said to have brought it to Tokyo in the Meiji eraThere was a time when no one performed it; Katsura Bunshi V is said to have revived it

Words and background

The punchline is hard to follow without knowing how hours were counted. Knowing about nihachi soba and Edo timekeeping makes the joke clear.

There are several theories about the name "nihachi soba" (literally "two-eight soba"). One is that a bowl cost sixteen mon (2 x 8); another is that the noodles were eight parts buckwheat flour to two parts wheat flour. Neither is settled. In the story the bill is sixteen mon, and the man hands over one-mon coins one at a time, counting "one, two, three..." until he reaches eight and asks, "What time is it?"

Edo hours were told by a system of variable hours: the time from dawn to dusk and from dusk to dawn were each divided into six. Noon and midnight were both "nine," and the number fell to eight, seven, then six (dawn six and dusk six), five and four before returning to nine. Because the length of an hour shifted with the seasons, the times below are approximate.

HourNight to morningDay to evening
Nineabout 12 a.m.about noon
Eightabout 2 a.m.about 2 p.m.
Sevenabout 4 a.m.about 4 p.m.
Sixdawn six (about 6 a.m.)dusk six (about 6 p.m.)
Fiveabout 8 a.m.about 8 p.m.
Fourabout 10 a.m.about 10 p.m.

What to listen for

If you are hearing it for the first time, watch the contrast between the first night and the second. On the first night, the man flatters the seller about everything: the sign, the chopsticks, the bowl, the broth, the fish cake. On the second night he follows the same routine while his disappointment in the shop grows.

When the man asks the time, the first night's answer is "nine" right after eight, so he goes on from ten and gains a coin. On the second night he has gone out too early, hears "four," and has to count again from five. With this counting in mind, you won't miss the joke.

Key scenes original dialogue written for this site

The smooth talker

  • The manHey, these chopsticks haven't been split yet? Nice. Fresh ones for every customer, that's the way to do it.
  • (Using a folded fan as chopsticks, he blows on the hot noodles and slurps them.)
  • The manGreat broth too. And you cut the chikuwa this thick? You making any money at all?

Counting the coins

  • The manAll I've got is small change, hold out your hand. One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight... what time is it?
  • Soba sellerIt's nine, sir.
  • The manTen, eleven, twelve... sixteen. Thanks for the meal.

The second stall

  • The man...The tips of these chopsticks are wet. Has somebody used these?
  • Soba sellerSaves me the trouble of washing them.
  • The manDon't save trouble there! ...Man, finding something to praise is going to be hard work.

This is not a transcription of any storyteller's performance. The plot, the sage and the way the coins are counted are traditional; the dialogue is written by this site.

Notable performers

More stories

Hear rakugo live at a yoseYose Guide: Rakugo Theaters in Tokyo, Kansai and Beyond →